Frage auf boardgamegeek - richtige Antwort?

Hi!
I have some short rules questions and would be thrilled if anybody would be so kind to answer them.

a) My A-Wing ends his move on an asteroid. He does not get his action and has to roll an attack die to check if he gets damaged. Is it possible to take critical damage by ramming an asteroid (if the die face rolled is in fact a critical hit)?
If the A-Wing continues to move in the next turn, does he have to check for damage again (as he starts his move on the asteroid) and will he lose his action too? If the A-Wing was stressed and it was a green move that landed him on the asteroid, does the stress token get removed? If not, does it get removed if the next move, that clears the ship from the asteroid, is a green maneuver?

b) If my stressed A-Wing executes a green maneuver and crashes into another ship, he loses his action. Does the stress marker get removed or not?

c) My Firespray with a Weapons Engineer already has a target lock on one X-Wing that is far away on the other side of the playing field. If the Firespray now target locks another enemy ship within range, does it have to drop the old target lock on the X-Wing?

Thanks so much!  

rashktah wrote:

a) My A-Wing ends his move on an asteroid. He does not get his action and has to roll an attack die to check if he gets damaged. Is it possible to take critical damage by ramming an asteroid (if the die face rolled is in fact a critical hit)?

Yes, it's possible to get a face-up damage card from hitting an asteroid.


rashktah wrote:

If the A-Wing continues to move in the next turn, does he have to check for damage again (as he starts his move on the asteroid) and will he lose his action too?

He does have to check for damage and will lose his action if his maneuver template or the end position of the ship in the next turn overlaps the asteroid again. Whether or not his starting position is on the asteroid is not of importance.


rashktah wrote:

If the A-Wing was stressed and it was a green move that landed him on the asteroid, does the stress token get removed? If not, does it get removed if the next move, that clears the ship from the asteroid, is a green maneuver?

Yes, one stress marker does get removed.


rashktah wrote:

b) If my stressed A-Wing executes a green maneuver and crashes into another ship, he loses his action. Does the stress marker get removed or not?

Yes, one stress marker gets removed.


rashktah wrote:

c) My Firespray with a Weapons Engineer already has a target lock on one X-Wing that is far away on the other side of the playing field. If the Firespray now target locks another enemy ship within range, does it have to drop the old target lock on the X-Wing?

Yes, unless you have some effect that explicitly allows you to maintain two target locks, you have to drop the old one in order to obtain a new one.

csaa4902 schrieb:
Abgesehen davon, dass die deutsche Regel das "überfliegen" von Asteroiden anders handhabt.
Was meint ihr? Kann man eine kritischen Schaden durch einen Asteroiden erhalten? Ich dachte nicht.

Sarge schrieb:
In meinem Deutschen Regelwerk ist das auch auf Seite 20 zu finden, wie im Englischen?!

Wenn es nach Ausführung eines Manövers dazu kommt, dass sich die Basis eines Schiffs und ein Hindernismarker überschneiden, ...

Corellianer schrieb:

Sarge schrieb:
In meinem Deutschen Regelwerk ist das auch auf Seite 20 zu finden, wie im Englischen?!

Ach im deutschen Regelbuch steht halt nur etwas wie:

Wenn es nach Ausführung eines Manövers dazu kommt, dass sich die Basis eines Schiffs und ein Hindernismarker überschneiden, ...

Es fehlt leider der Teil, der die Überlappung der Manöverschablone mit dem Hindernis behandelt.

BTW: Dies führte in Itzehoe zu einer 10min Diskussion mit einem meiner Gegner, weil dieser darauf bestand, einfach unbeschadet über Asteroiden fliegen zu dürfen, so lange die Schiffsbase anschließend nicht darauf landet.

Sarge schrieb:
Das wurde ja offiziell von FFG bzw. den Heidelbären richtig gestellt.
Wir haben ja oben den Link in Laminidas Posting zu Udos Thread zu dem Thema.

Thrawn schrieb:Schon krass: X-Wing hat im Vergleich zu anderen Tabletops, wie z.B. BattleTech, echt wenige bzw. überschaubare Regeln. Jedoch braucht man anscheinend Seiten von Errata etc. um diese für die Community zu konkretisieren. Hoffentlich bringt FFG bald mehr Struktur und Logik in das X-Wing-Regelwerk.